Magnesium Alloy or Aluminum Alloy? A Comprehensive Comparison of 7 Major Die-Casting Differences – D

Time:2026-11-11 09:53:28 / Popularity: / Source:

In Lightweighting Wave, Material Choice Determines Product Competitiveness
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
What is Magnesium Alloy? Characteristics of Magnesium Alloy Materials and Their Applications in Industrial Design - You Concept
Darling of Lightweighting: Why is Magnesium Alloy So Popular?
For every 10% reduction in weight, range of new energy vehicles can increase by 5%-6%. In this era where "weight reduction equals increased range," magnesium alloy, as the lightest metal structural material currently used in engineering applications, is shining brightly in fields such as automotive electronics, aerospace, and communication equipment.
Magnesium has a density of only 1.738 g/cm³, a full 35% lighter than aluminum's 2.7 g/cm³! Research data shows that, while maintaining structural consistency, replacing aluminum alloy with magnesium alloy in manufacture of electric drive housings can reduce weight by as much as 29.7%. What does this mean? An electric vehicle with a range of 500 kilometers can travel nearly 15 kilometers more after replacing its components with magnesium alloy parts.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
But magnesium alloys, "lightweight champions," are not so easy to handle. Their chemical reactivity means they begin to burn when heated to 632℃ in air, and loose, porous oxide film on their surface cannot prevent further oxygen intrusion. In contrast, dense oxide film on the surface of aluminum alloys acts like a protective suit, keeping them stable.
It is precisely this difference in characteristics that leads magnesium and aluminum alloys down completely different paths in high-pressure die-casting production.
Smelting Process: One Requires Care, the Other Can Be Handled Freely
Melting Point Difference: Magnesium alloys generally have a melting point of 430-630℃, while aluminum alloys are slightly higher, at 580-670℃. Interestingly, in actual production, to ensure melt fluidity, die-casting temperature for magnesium alloys is often controlled at 630-680℃, while for aluminum alloys it is 650-720℃. This leads to an interesting phenomenon: magnesium alloys, with their lower melting point, are produced at temperatures not much different from aluminum alloys.
Smelting Protection: This is Real Dividing Line! Magnesium molten metal ignites upon contact with oxygen, requiring a dedicated gas-protected melting furnace with a tightly sealed SF₆ + CO₂/N₂ gas mixture for gating system. Aluminum alloys, on the other hand, are much less demanding; conventional covering agents or nitrogen protection suffice, and sometimes even complete exposure is acceptable.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
Melting Furnace Structure
Flowability: Magnesium Alloys "Run Fast" but Also "Cool Down Quickly"
Magnesium alloys have better flowability than aluminum alloys, with lower surface tension, allowing them to fill every corner of mold. This characteristic enables magnesium alloys to be produced with wall thicknesses as thin as 0.3mm and injection speeds up to 10m/s, making them particularly suitable for producing precision thin-walled parts.
However, every advantage has its disadvantages. Heat transfer rate of molten magnesium alloy to mold is extremely fast, and its latent heat of solidification is lower than that of aluminum alloys, meaning it "cools down quickly." Premature solidification during filling process can cause molding defects. Therefore, magnesium alloy die casting requires rapid filling, placing high demands on power of injection system.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
Thin-Wall Parts Machining Process: Technology, Challenges, and Solutions - Speed-Up
Equipment Selection: Hot Chamber or Cold Chamber, That Is Question. Choosing wrong die-casting machine can ruin the entire product.
Small magnesium alloy parts (under 1kg) are mostly made using hot chamber die-casting machines. Furnace and injection system are sealed together, reducing risk of melt oxidation and increasing production efficiency. Large magnesium alloy castings are made using cold chamber die-casting machines.
Aluminum alloys are mostly made using cold chamber die-casting machines. Furnace and injection system are separate, not limited by high-melting-point alloys, making it suitable for forming large parts and high-melting-point alloys.
Regarding injection pressure, aluminum alloys require high pressures of 80-120 MPa, while magnesium alloys, due to their good fluidity, only need 40-100 MPa.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
Mold Temperature and Cooling: Precise Temperature Control is Key.
Magnesium alloys are particularly sensitive to temperature. Mold needs to be preheated to 200-240℃ (mold temperature controller set at 300-320℃) to delay premature solidification of melt. Aluminum alloy molds have a relatively lower temperature, 180-220℃, but thin-walled parts also require 200-240℃.
In terms of cooling system design, magnesium alloys, due to their rapid solidification and short cooling time, require molds with highly efficient cooling channels. A combination of oil cooling and a mold temperature controller is typically used for precise temperature control. Here's a little-known fact: magnesium alloy molds experience less wear than aluminum alloy molds, mainly because aluminum alloy melt has a higher viscosity.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
"Ouneng Machinery" provides complete solutions for intelligent temperature control islands for die-casting molds!
Safety and Environmental Protection: Magnesium Alloy Production is Like "Mine Clearance"
Speaking of safety measures, magnesium alloy production is definitely a "high-risk operation." Dust is flammable, melt explodes upon contact with water, and SF₆ is a strong greenhouse gas—each of these must be strictly controlled. Workshop needs to be equipped with a dedicated fire extinguishing system and explosion-proof ventilation devices. Safety facility investment for a single production line is 500,000-800,000 yuan higher than that for an aluminum processing line.
In comparison, aluminum alloys have lower risks, but ventilation and dust control are still essential.
It is worth mentioning that semi-solid die-casting technology can completely eliminate reliance on protective gases and is becoming an important direction for magnesium alloy forming. This technology is not only safer but also more environmentally friendly.
Post-treatment and Corrosion Protection: How to Address Weaknesses of Magnesium Alloys?
Magnesium has high chemical reactivity and a low standard electrode potential (-2.37V), making it highly susceptible to electrochemical corrosion. Oxide film formed on the surface has a loose structure, and once damaged, it loses its protective function. In humid, saline environments, corrosion rate of magnesium accelerates significantly.
Therefore, magnesium alloy products must undergo surface treatment processes such as chemical conversion and micro-arc oxidation before use. Studies have shown that magnesium alloys treated with micro-arc oxidation have an increased self-corrosion potential of approximately 300mV and an increase in impedance of 2-3 orders of magnitude. If powder coating is added, corrosion resistance will be even stronger.
Micro-arc Oxidation Technology Information - Document Home
Aluminum alloys are much less troublesome. Under normal conditions, no additional protection is needed; shot blasting is generally sufficient to meet basic corrosion resistance requirements. In terms of cost, aluminum alloy anodizing costs approximately 18-25 yuan/㎡, while magnesium alloy micro-arc oxidation costs 30-40 yuan/㎡, nearly double cost.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
Cost and Application: Calculating Economics
Raw Material Costs: The latest data from 2025 shows that market price of magnesium ingots is 16,000 yuan/ton, and aluminum ingots are 19,500 yuan/ton. Looking at raw materials alone, magnesium costs 18% less than aluminum for same weight, and due to its lower density, cost is directly reduced by 45% for same volume.
Processing Costs: This is the key! Processing costs account for 62% of the total cost of magnesium alloys, while aluminum alloy processing costs account for only 41%. The total cost of magnesium alloy for new energy vehicle battery trays is approximately 28,000 yuan/ton, while same aluminum alloy component costs only 22,000 yuan/ton, making magnesium alloy 27% more expensive.
Chart 5: Cost Ratio of Magnesium Alloy to Aluminum Alloy (Materials Used per Unit Volume)
  Density (g/cm²) Unit Volume (1m³) Metal Weight (t) Unit Price (Yuan/t) Metal Cost per Unit Volume (1m²) (Yuan/m²) Cost Ratio of Magnesium Alloy to Aluminum Alloy
Magnesium Alloy 1.8 1.8 19839 35710 64%
Aluminum Alloy 2.7 2.7 20740 55998
Application Scenarios: Magnesium alloys are widely used in automotive parts with high lightweight requirements (dashboards, steering brackets, timing covers) and 3C products (camera frames, electronic housings). Magnesium alloys also excel in communication equipment due to their good thermal conductivity and excellent electromagnetic shielding properties.
Aluminum alloys, on the other hand, are widely used in automotive, aerospace, and building structural components, with a wider range of applications and a more mature industrial chain.
Typical applications of magnesium alloys in automobiles
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
Future Trends: Is Magnesium Replacing Aluminum Inevitable?
With breakthroughs in semi-solid forming technology, magnesium alloy die casting is shedding its label of "high safety and cost." Pass rate for electric drive housings produced using semi-solid processes has increased from 78% to 95%, while the overall cost has decreased by 18%.
Amount of magnesium used per new energy vehicle is projected to reach 25 kg by 2025, a 67% increase compared to 2023. In emerging fields such as low-altitude economy and humanoid robots, specific strength advantage of magnesium alloys is irreplaceable by aluminum alloys.
Material selection is not black and white, but rather about adapting to application scenario. In scenarios where weight increases and benefits of lightweighting are greater, magnesium alloys offer superior cost-effectiveness, such as structural components for new energy vehicles and parts for low-altitude aircraft. In scenarios with low weight and low added value, aluminum alloys have a cost advantage.
Slider Ejector Pin Design 
In conclusion, magnesium alloys and aluminum alloys each have their own characteristics. Magnesium alloys are light, thin, and quick to manufacture, but delicate; aluminum alloys are stable, economical, and reliable, but heavy. Under major trend of lightweighting, "comeback" of magnesium alloys is only a matter of time.

Go To Top